• About
  • Events
  • News
  • Newsletter
Adviser Home
  • CPD Centre
  • Development Solutions
    • AXA Investment Managers
    • Momentum Global Investment Management
    • Tacit Investment Management
    • Aegon Corporate Protection
    • Tax Planning Support
    • Outsourced Investments
    • Orbis Invest Differently
    • FundsNetwork
    • Brooks Macdonald
    • Aegon - Supporting financial advice
    • Tax Planning Investments
  • Resources
    • Technical
      • BPR due diligence video
      • Investment Planning; November inflation numbers and more.
      • Investment planning; global dividend payments, RPI Calculation and more.
      • Financial planning considerations around Pensions, Investment Accounts and ISAs
    • Regulation
      • Money Marketing - Implementing the Consumer Duty
      • Manak Solicitors - A guide to debt relief orders
      • Citywire - Podcast: Consumer Duty rules more important than RDR
      • FCA - Changes to LIBOR as of end-2021
      • Pictet Asset Management - Geoengineering solutions to climate change
      • Pictet Asset Management - ESG in Practice series: Cédric Lecamp on engagement in the Water strategy
      • Objectway OWIN Talk S02E03: Top drivers and main challenges in ESG adoption
      • THE WEALTH MOSAIC - WealthTech Talks: Wealth Managers, ESG and the Role of Technology
      • Citywire & AXA IM - ESG & Me: Europe
      • Q121 Business Relief Quarterly Update: What’s the score with Business Relief and excepted cash assets?
      • Financial Conduct Authority - CP21/18: Enhancing climate-related disclosures by standard listed companies
      • Financial Conduct Authority - CP21/17: Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers and FCA-regulated pension providers
      • Financial Conduct Authority - FG21/1 Guidance for firms on the fair treatment of vulnerable customers
      • FCA’s expectations on financial resilience for FCA solo-regulated firms – statement update
      • An honest view of ESG: Matthew Jellicoe
      • ESG Viewpoint: Coal's Uncertain Future
      • How to combat pensions scams
      • How the Pension Schemes Act will affect your clients
      • IFAs and regulators must focus on drawdown underspending
      • How Will Regulatory Changes Impact ESG?
      • What the US election result could mean for markets
      • The Money Marketing Podcast: US Election Special
      • A guide to ESG and responsible investing
      • Is ESG for the money or the morals?
      • Inducements - what's in and what's out?
      • Investment scams booklet
      • The role of stewardship in ESG
      • The performance review: We put 10 ESG UK equity funds under the microscope
      • Are DFMs meeting the ESG challenge?
      • Increases to the state pension and lifetime allowance
      • Pensions & ESG – the DWP strikes back
      • FCA focus on ‘sustainable finance’ set to increase
      • An asset class growing in popularity: What advisers need to know about peer-to-peer lending
      • A practical guide to Pension Transfers from defined benefit to defined contribution
      • How to manage your CPD
      • What do high UK government debt levels mean?
      • Next state pension age review must assess Covid-19 factor
    • Marketing
      • The Yardstick Agency - Harness LinkedIn’s power with these 6 practical ideas from our favourite experts.
      • The Yardstick Agency - Are brochures still relevant in 2022?
      • The Yardstick Agency - Comment. Like. Share. Why most LinkedIn users choose the wrong option
      • Faith Liversedge: How to convert clients to your ongoing service
      • FTAdviser - Guide to the future of advice
      • The Yardstick Agency - 4 things you should never leave off your website’s fees page
      • Money Marketing - Podcast: Do we expect more for less from advisers?
      • AdviceBridge - The figures don’t lie: Why advice firms must provide all three engagement channels (adviser, digital, and hybrid) for all client types
      • Personal Finance Society - What It Means to Tell a Good Story About Your Business
      • The Yardstick Agency - 3 simple changes every adviser and planner can make now to get more referrals
      • The Yardstick Agency - 6 occasions when being too cautious will damage your marketing
      • Objectway OWIN Talk S03E04: Hyper-Personalization in the context of investor risk profiling
      • Objectway OWIN Talk S04E01 - Client Experience: a digital journey that is achievable
      • Objectway OWIN Talk S04E02: Use digital change to improve the 'WOW factor' for clients
      • Objectway OWIN Talk S04E03: Has the pandemic accelerated adoption of new technology in wealth management firms?
      • Objectway OWIN Talk S04E04: Treat different people differently
      • Objectway OWIN Talk S04E05: Are you managing wealth or client experience? Pt.1
      • Objectway OWIN Talk S04E06: Are you managing wealth or client experience? Pt.2
      • THE WEALTH MOSAIC - WealthTech Talks: Getting the most out of data in wealth management
      • Harvard Business Review - Marketing in the Age of Resistance
      • Backlinko - WE ANALYZED 11.8 MILLION GOOGLE SEARCH RESULTS Here’s What We Learned About SEO
      • Enhance Your Email Personalization: 6 Best Practices for Standing Out in the Inbox in 2021.
      • Navigating the new normal: how marketers can humanise and personalise the consumer experience
      • Building Customer Trust: The Stages to Leveraging Preference Management
      • Successful Strategies to Win New Business
      • How to build a digital adviser. Part 1: your website
      • How to build a digital adviser. Part 2: emails
      • How to build a digital adviser Part 4: social media
      • Your Guide to Business Development in the New Normal
      • Creating a successful digital advice model
      • A simple guide to Metadata
      • Blogging Checklist
      • Marketing Checklist
      • SEO checklist
      • Website checklist
      • Case Studies
      • Investment Guides
      • ABI Making Retirement Options Clear
      • Equity Release - Not For Me
      • PMI - New Market Opportunities
      • Social Media Training
      • Adviser PR
      • Web Review Service
      • Communication Reviews
      • Corporate Design
      • Tailored Web Development
      • E Mail Marketing and Communications
      • Unconscious beliefs ‘key’ to sticking to advice plan
      • Advisers must embrace digital tech, just like their clients
      • The Insiders' Guide on How to Grow Your Business During Lockdown
      • Trends 2021: Selective innovation and getting personal
    • Team Development
      • ISO 22222 - Increase your professional standards
      • SOLLA - Later Life Adviser Accreditation
      • FTAdviser - How to manage the transition back to the office
    • Technology
      • Increase client face to face time
    • Proposition
      • FTAdviser - Can advisers afford to ignore crypto?
      • Citywire New Model Adviser Podcast: Why advisers should care about decentralised finance.
      • FTAdviser - Investing in emerging markets after Covid
      • FTAdviser - Q&A: Advisers are missing a trick with business protection
      • FTAdviser - How to get younger clients on board with financial advice
      • Momentum Sustainable Managed Portfolios.
      • Intelligent Partnership - Alternative Investment Market: Industry Update - March  2022
      • Money Marketing: The future of advice is going to be dynamic
      • Aviva - 9 FinTech areas to focus on in 2022
      • PruAdviser - Investment Office Insights Q1 2022 – Inflation, Technology Stocks and COP26 Summit
      • Sustainable Living: A Homeowner's Guide to Maximising Energy Efficiency During COVID-19 and Beyond
      • Octopus Investments - An Adviser’s Guide to the Enterprise Investment Scheme
      • Schroders - Podcast: Finding the next generation of mega caps
      • Pictet Asset Management & the Institute of International Finance - Bonds that build back better
      • Retail Merchant Services - An SME’s Guide to Reducing Your Carbon Footprint and Environmental Impact
      • Trusted Reviews - Sustainable technology: understanding the latest innovations and initiatives from tech giants
      • Citywire - Comeback kids: The 10 best-performing funds of 2021
      • Citywire - Secret Pension Fund Manager: How to spot a fraud
      • Citywire - Seven risks investors need to prepare for in 2022
      • Energy Helpline - A Guide to Global Internet Energy Usage
      • Intelligent Partnership - November 2021 AIM Industry Update
      • Royal London - What stops people from seeking financial advice?
      • Stanmore - Sustainable Housing Guide
      • comparethemarket.com Guide - Choosing Ethical Banking: The Eco-Friendly Way
      • AXA Investment Management - Why a socially aware investment approach pays dividends
      • FTAdviser - Advisers sticking with equities despite market uncertainty
      • FTAdviser - If your business is to thrive, you will have to advise remotely
      • Always Be Content - Dare to Care: How Doing Good Helps Business Do Better
      • Finding your advice style with lifestyle planning
      • Aegon - How your clients can become a financial wellbeing ‘all-rounder’
      • PruAdviser - The power of advice report: Advisers as agents of change for sustainable investing
      • Aviva - Generation rent: the protection they need
      • FTAdviser - How suitable are financial products for young savers?
      • Schroders - Has Covid actually mattered to financial markets?
      • Aegon adviser attitudes report 2021: Cost, Coronavirus and ESG shape investment trends
      • AIG - How to: reinvigorate your critical illness sales process (CPD)
      • AIG - Planning for Later Life Care - Update (CPD)
      • Royal London - Does sustainable investing belong in fixed income?
      • Intelligent Partnership - Q121 AIM Relief Quarterly Update
      • Fidelity International - Intergenerational Planning Synopsis
      • Advisor Perspectives - Why Prospects Choose You
      • Advisor Perspectives: 10 Signs You Need to Be a “Hybrid” Advisor
      • This is Money - Mind the money age gap: Research claims over-65s are smarter about pensions and investing due to a lack of financial education for the young
      • Aviva - Retirement in the time of coronavirus
      • M&G Investments - How to invest today to meet tomorrow’s challenges
      • Aviva - A quarter made a bad debt decision during pandemic
      • Schroders - Not all ESG bonds are created equal - here's why
      • Schroders - Why EM is the perfect place for impact investing
      • Schroders - How might higher inflation affect your portfolio?
      • Intelligent Partnership - A Professional’s Guide to Estate Planning
      • The Institute for Fiscal Studies - Understanding the gender pension gap
      • Momentum Global Investment Management - Retirement Income Dilemma
      • The world in 2030: Investing for the next decade
      • Is now the right time to be adding risk?
      • Your clients’ retirement could have been hit three ways by 2020
      • How to introduce clients to protection
      • The Insiders’ Guide on How to Grow Your Business During Lockdown
      • Value vs. growth - who wins?
      • Building a Living Pension
      • Why 2021 could be the year of the Ssas
      • The New Protection Challenge
      • The best and worst performing funds of 2020
      • FTSE soars 3.1% on first trading day of 2021
      • Demand for advice set to 'grow exponentially' this year
      • Handling vulnerable clients who want equity release
      • Preparing your clients for a K shaped recovery
      • Shift in retirement journeys set to reshape the market
      • Managing risk in volatile markets
      • State pension now a whole lot more important for planners’ clients
      • Govt boosts support for self-employed during lockdown
      • Covid-19 job cuts cause over 55s to re-think retirement plans
      • Covid has changed advice needs
      • ESG for income and growth
      • Savings surge is an adviser opportunity
      • Four in five UK adults say they don’t have a ‘pension will’
      • Combining pensions and property
      • Why transfers in drawdown will be a key theme for advisers
      • Clever Adviser Technology Ltd
      • The Value of Advice - an insiders guide
      • The Value of Advice
      • Adviser Home Guide to Innovation
      • Designing your service proposition
      • Effective Cash Management
      • A managed sale, move and funding service for your retired clients
      • Private Medical Insurance
      • Portfolio Comparison
      • Cashflow Modelling App
      • Defaqto Engage Core
      • Protection advice made simple
      • Client Reports and Online Paraplanning
      • Technical Support
      • Guide to the changing face of protection cover
      • Advising on income protection
      • Business Protection
      • The future of cashflow modelling
      • Equity available in UK homes soars to £600bn
      • Battling the pension scammers
      • Billy Burrows: The way we advise clients will change
      • Why advice finally feels relevant
      • South West: Bonds we can depend on
      • Pandemic forcing a widespread rethink of retirement plans
      • Guide To Post-Covid-19 Retirement Planning
      • Global Investor Behaviours and Attitudes: A Cross Generational Overview
      • Rohan Sivajoti: The one page business plan
      • Protection conversations increasingly common for advisers
      • Generate new business with tax-efficient investments
      • Fixed income in the new normal
      • The risks that investors should prepare for in 2021
      • FTSE sinks 3% amid Covid chaos
      • Longevity: The hub of retirement planning
      • Are investors adjusting to the new normal?
      • Women urged to check pensions for underpayment
      • How to manage pitfalls of giving wealth to next generation
      • The dangers of drawing too much, too soon
    • Adviser Business In Testing Times
  • Sustainable Investments
    • Sustainable Investing - Schroders
    • Sustainable Investing - Hermes
    • Sustainable Investments - Pictet
    • Sustainable Investing - M&G
  • About
  • Events
  • News
  • Newsletter

Financial Services Compensation Scheme funding

To The Right Honourable ..

Financial Services Compensation Scheme funding

(I am a Director and shareholder in a Chartered Financial Planning business in the City of London.) I would like to draw to your attention a situation that is developing within our industry that poses a threat to small businesses like ours, a business which provides employment opportunities and helps to drive growth.

The Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) is funded via annual and interim levies on FCA and PRA authorised firms, of which we are one (https://www.fscs.org.uk/about-us/funding/). My understanding is that these levies are calculated with reference to the level of investment intermediation carried out each financial year by each firm, measured in terms of fees received.

The total FSCS budget now exceeds the FCA’s budget, meaning compensation costs now exceed regulatory costs, and this trend is set to continue.

There has been a significant rise in the number of claims on the FSCS in this financial year, mainly in relation to pension advice. There have been a number of high profile scandals, the most prominent being the British Steel Pension Scheme, and according to the FSCS £162m of total costs of £237m were in relation to pension advice.

In addition, Reyker Capital and SVS Securities both failed, which is likely to result in claims. Having already seen a marked increase in regulatory costs, the FSCS have now hit firms with an interim levy totalling £46m.

Whilst we were aware of the interim levy being imminent, we were shocked to receive an email from the FSCS demanding we pay an interim levy of £4,465.99, with one month given to pay. If the invoice is not settled within one month, there is a fine of £250 plus interest accruing daily. We had already paid £18,768.60 in July 2019 to cover the 2019/20 regulatory fees. Our turnover is just under £1.2m.

 
The fundamental problem with this system is the levy calculation. Firms can act unscrupulously with inadequate professional indemnity (PI) insurance, knowing that if claims arise they can allow the company to become insolvent and leave investors to fall back on the FSCS. Meanwhile, firms like ours - who are unlikely to ever cause a claim on the FSCS due to the type of products we recommend and advice we give and who hold significant PI cover - have to pay higher levies to effectively cover the rogue firms.

Consequently, we have a perverse situation whereby the most successful, well resourced and insured firms, are paying increasingly higher amounts to protect customers of firms who have not acted with integrity and often have inadequate insurance cover. In the insurance market, the reverse would apply i.e. the lowest risk firms pay the least and the highest risk firms pay the most.

It is a widely held view within the financial planning industry that the current funding basis is not fit for purpose. The burden is being placed in the wrong businesses and ultimately this could lead to some of these businesses failing. Moreover, higher regulatory costs lead to higher fees for clients, so those clients of successful and well run firms will end up footing the bill.

The claims on the FSCS during 2019/20 are potentially only the tip of the iceberg. The claims resulting from British Steel are likely to put more pressure on the FSCS and there is a real risk that the issue of defined benefit transfers results in £billions in compensation, which could be catastrophic for the industry and the FSCS.

How will businesses like ours be able to afford a demand for an interim levy of tens of thousands of pounds with one month’s notice? The impact could be extremely damaging across the advice sector.

There are a number of potential solutions and the FCA have already consulted on FSCS funding options. My personal view is that the levy should be risk-based, in the way that PI premiums are risk-based, meaning for example that those firms selling unregulated products or doing an excessive large number of defined benefit transfers pay more than those firms who take a more vanilla approach.

The funding basis used by the Pension Protection Fund (PPF) provides a good example of how a risk-based model could work. The PPF measures the risk of each sponsoring employer falling into the scheme, and sets the levy according to the level of risk. Consequently, the companies least likely to become insolvent are paying a levy that reflects the fact that the pension scheme is unlikely to need to be covered by the PPF. A less financially secure company, with a pension scheme in deficit, is more likely to become insolvent and therefore the pension scheme is more likely to fall into the PPF, meaning they pay a higher levy. This seems like common sense to me.

I cannot see why the FSCS / FCA cannot take a similar approach in calculating levies on eligible firms. In much the same way as PI insurers calculate our insurance premium, the FSCS could assess the risk of each firm in terms of the types of advice being given, and set the levy accordingly. The FCA certainly have sufficient data to assess risk, under the Retail Mediation Activities (RMA) return. This would end the unacceptable situation of the lowest risk and most well resourced firms providing an open-ended source of funds to pay out for the misdemeanours of those firms who take advantage of their “customers”. The present system actually encourages risk taking and scams.

There are other potential solutions. For example, a product levy paid by providers, or a levy on policyholders, but the FCA do not seem keen on either of these solutions. Ultimately, the burden needs to be spread more evenly and widely. Our professional body, the Personal Finance Society, has put forward the idea of merging the FSCS levy with the cost of PI insurance, which has merit. There are issues with PI that are interlinked with the funding basis I am highlighting in this letter, but outside of the narrow point I am raising with you.

Ultimately, the burden needs to be spread both more fairly and widely, with greater accountability and cost falling on those most likely to cause an increase in the amount claimed under the scheme.

I would be grateful if you could give my concerns some consideration and raise this issue with HM Treasury.

Your sincerely,

  

Back

Our Sponsors & Partners

Funds Network
Octopus Investments
Orbis
Momentum Global Investment Management
Schroders
Pictet Asset Manegement
Brooks Macdonald
Clear
Aegon
Previous
Next

Contact Us

  • Partners
  • Contact Us
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Data / GDPR
  • Privacy Statement

Social

Follow us to stay up to date with the latest industry news

  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Newsletter Sign Up

Fancy getting all the latest news direct to your inbox?

Please do not fill in the above field to help us identify genuine requests.

Adviser Home

© 2022 Adviser Home

Website by Clear

Back To Top

Sign up to the Adviser Home newsletter

Please leave the above box empty.

After you register your details with us we will communicate with you by email as follows:

Each week you will receive an update bulletin “InfoMix”. You will also receive, normally weekly, a single email on a subject of relevance to your role as adviser or provider.

For providers we will also from time to time - normally 3 or four times a year, tell you about Adviser Home initiatives or opportunities for you to partner with us.

At any time you can elect to stop receiving emails by unsubscribing.

Your data will only be shared with a third party with your specific written agreement. Our full GDPR policy is found here

Please leave the above box empty.

Please leave the above box empty.